Bisexual Representation in Fiction and Missed Nuance
Authors frequently treat bisexuality as a plot device rather than a stable, lived identity. This oversight stems from a reliance on monosexual perspectives, where a character's orientation is only validated through a current relationship. Because of this, the internal stability of being bisexual is ignored, and the focus shifts to how the character fits into a binary world. This creates a disconnect between fictional portrayals and the actual, diverse experiences of the community.
How does the 'erasure' of bisexuality manifest through the assumption that a character's sexual orientation is defined solely by their current partner?
The assumption that a character's sexuality is defined by their current partner effectively renders their internal identity invisible, forcing them into a binary box based on external optics.
- Heteronormativity: Characters in opposite-sex relationships are frequently coded as straight, ignoring the reality that attraction remains independent of marriage or dating status.
- Homonormativity: Characters in same-sex relationships are often assumed to be gay or lesbian, which strips them of their specific bisexual history and lived experience.
- Visual cues: Writers rely on the gender of a character's partner as a shorthand for orientation, which fails to reflect the complexity of human desire.
- Relationship status: The focus on who a character is currently sleeping with obscures the fact that bisexuality is a persistent, internal orientation.
Quick facts
| Category | Reality | Fiction |
|---|---|---|
| Identity | Stable, internal | Partner-dependent |
| Monogamy | Common | Rarely depicted |
| Terminology | Explicit usage | Often avoided |
In what ways do fictional narratives reinforce the harmful stereotype that bisexual individuals are inherently promiscuous or incapable of monogamy?
Fictional narratives often equate the capacity to love multiple genders with a lack of boundaries, fueling the false narrative that bisexual people are inherently non-monogamous or prone to infidelity.
- Writers frequently introduce a third party into a stable relationship specifically to "test" the bisexual character's loyalty.
- Dialogue often frames a character's attraction to multiple genders as a "need for variety" rather than a capacity for connection.
- Plot points often hinge on the character being unable to choose between two partners of different genders.
- The narrative structure rarely allows a bisexual character to express long-term commitment without questioning their own desires.
- Jealousy arcs are disproportionately assigned to the partners of bisexual characters.
What is the impact of the 'gold star' or 'gatekeeping' rhetoric often found in queer narratives on the portrayal of bisexual characters?
Yes. This gatekeeping rhetoric, which suggests one must be exclusively same-sex attracted to be "truly" queer, forces characters to prove their legitimacy. Studies show that roughly 40% of bisexual individuals report feeling excluded from LGBTQ+ spaces, a sentiment often mirrored in literature where bisexual characters are treated as outsiders.
How does the lack of explicit terminology—such as characters who experience attraction to multiple genders but never identify as bisexual—contribute to the invisibility of the identity?
When characters express attraction to multiple genders but avoid the label "bisexual," it reinforces the idea that the identity is something to be ashamed of or avoided. This practice suggests that being "queer" or "fluid" is acceptable, but specifically claiming the bisexual label is too polarizing or confusing for the audience. By denying characters the language to describe themselves, writers miss the opportunity to normalize the term and provide representation for those who find comfort in the word itself.
For example, in many prestige dramas, characters might engage in same-sex encounters while maintaining a "don't label me" stance, which functions as a narrative shield against biphobia. A notable exception exists in some contemporary young adult fiction, where characters explicitly use the word "bisexual" to describe their experiences. This usage provides a necessary sense of clarity and belonging for readers who are looking for their own experiences reflected on the page.
To what extent do fictional depictions fail to acknowledge the unique social and mental health challenges faced specifically by the bisexual community?
No. Fictional depictions rarely address the fact that bisexual individuals experience higher rates of anxiety and depression compared to their monosexual peers. While these mental health disparities are well-documented in clinical research, they are almost never woven into the character development or the broader social context of a fictional story.
How does the 'bisexual villain' trope perpetuate the idea that fluidity in attraction equates to a lack of moral or ethical stability?
The "bisexual villain" trope relies on the outdated psychological assumption that a lack of rigid boundaries in attraction mirrors a lack of moral or ethical boundaries. By associating a character’s fluidity with deception, betrayal, or a "double life," writers suggest that someone who can love anyone is ultimately loyal to no one. This trope turns the character's capacity for broad attraction into a character flaw, framing their sexuality as the root cause of their villainy rather than an incidental aspect of their personality.
A classic example is the "femme fatale" archetype who uses her attraction to both men and women to manipulate others for personal gain. However, some modern thrillers have begun to subvert this by separating the character's sexuality from their moral choices. These stories show that a bisexual character can be a villain for the same reasons as anyone else, without their orientation being used as a metaphor for their capacity for malice.
What role does intersectionality play in how bisexuality is represented, particularly regarding race, gender expression, and socioeconomic status?
Intersectionality is essential because a person’s experience of bisexuality is shaped by their race, class, and gender presentation. For instance, a bisexual person of color may face different stereotypes regarding their sexuality than a white bisexual person, often tied to historical prejudices. A lot of people assume that bisexuality is a uniform experience across all demographics, but it is deeply influenced by how society views a person’s other identities. A character’s socioeconomic status might also dictate how safely they can express their sexuality, as financial independence often provides more freedom to be open.
Common mistakes
- Equating partners with identity. Don't assume a character's orientation changes based on who they date; make sure their internal sense of self remains consistent regardless of their partner.
- Using ambiguity as a crutch. Avoid leaving a character's sexuality undefined to keep them "relatable" to a general audience, as this effectively erases the specific reality of being bisexual.
- Relying on the 'phase' trope. Stop treating bisexuality as a bridge to a monosexual label, as this invalidates the long-term existence of the identity.
Writing Authentic Bisexual Characters
Focus on the consistency of a character's internal attraction rather than the gender of their current partner. By grounding their identity in their own history, you create a more accurate and respectful representation of the bisexual experience.